Q1. The concept of "human development ethics" challenges the Human Development Index (HDI) for its:
- (a) Implicit assumptions about universal values and development goals
- (b) Over-reliance on economic data
- (c) Exclusion of military strength indicators
- (d) Lack of international trade analysis
Answer & solution
Answer: (a) Implicit assumptions about universal values and development goals
The critique of 'human development ethics' argues that the HDI embeds implicit assumptions about what constitutes a good or developed life (e.g., long life, education, income) that may not align with all cultural or ethical frameworks. Critics argue these reflect a Western-centric view of universal values and development goals.
Option 2 (Over-reliance on economic data): The HDI actually broadens beyond purely economic measures by including health and education; this is not the core ethical critique.
Option 3 (Exclusion of military strength): Military strength is deliberately excluded from development indices as it does not reflect human welfare.
Option 4 (Lack of international trade analysis): Trade analysis is outside the scope of HDI, and this is not an ethical challenge raised by human development ethics.