Q1. The "capability approach" as applied to the Human Development Index (HDI) has been criticized for:
- (a) Being too focused on economic factors.
- (b) Being difficult to operationalize and measure.
- (c) Ignoring life expectancy.
- (d) Overemphasizing educational data.
Answer & solution
Answer: (b) Being difficult to operationalize and measure.
The 'capability approach', developed by Amartya Sen and applied to the HDI, focuses on expanding people's capabilities and freedoms. While theoretically rich, it has been criticized for being difficult to operationalize and measure in practice. Capabilities like freedom, dignity, and quality of life are hard to quantify, making it challenging to construct a reliable index.
The capability approach is actually LESS focused on economic factors (like GDP) and more on human well-being — so Option 1 is incorrect.
It does NOT ignore life expectancy — the HDI includes life expectancy as a key component.
The capability approach does not overemphasize educational data — it treats education as just one of several dimensions.