Q1. Which Act provided the legal basis for the creation of Pakistan?
- (a) Cabinet Mission Plan
- (b) Indian Independence Act, 1947
- (c) Government of India Act, 1935
- (d) Mountbatten Plan
Answer & solution
Answer: (b) Indian Independence Act, 1947
The Indian Independence Act, 1947 provided the legal basis for the creation of Pakistan (and independent India). Key provisions of the Indian Independence Act, 1947: Passed by the British Parliament on July 18, 1947; Created two independent dominions: India (from the existing British India excluding the areas that became Pakistan) and Pakistan (comprising West Punjab, Sindh, Balochistan , North-West Frontier Province, and East Bengal); Effective from August 14, 1947 (Pakistan's independence) and August 15, 1947 (India's independence); Ended British suzerainty over princely states — they were free to join either dominion or remain independent; Established the position of Governor-General in each dominion (Lord Mountbatten for India, Muhammad Ali Jinnah for Pakistan); The British Crown's authority over British India ended; Background: The Act was based on the 3 June Plan (Mountbatten Plan) announced on June 3, 1947, which proposed the partition of British India; Lord Mountbatten announced the Partition Plan on June 3, 1947; the Indian Independence Act was the legislative instrument that gave it legal effect.
Option (a) Cabinet Mission Plan — Incorrect: The Cabinet Mission Plan (1946) proposed a united India with a three-tier federal structure (groups of provinces); it was meant to AVOID partition, not create Pakistan; when it was rejected by the Congress and Muslim League couldn't agree, it ultimately paved the way for partition but was not the legal basis for Pakistan's creation.
Option (c) Government of India Act, 1935 — Incorrect: The Government of India Act, 1935 reorganized British India's governance structure (introduced provincial autonomy, All-India Federation concept) but it did NOT create Pakistan; it was the framework that India and Pakistan largely used as their provisional constitutions until their own constitutions were framed.
Option (d) Mountbatten Plan — Incorrect: The Mountbatten Plan (3 June Plan, 1947) was the political announcement/proposal for partition of British India — but it was NOT the legal/legislative instrument; the Indian Independence Act, 1947 passed by the British Parliament gave legal effect to the Mountbatten Plan and created the two dominions.