Q1. The Directive Principles of State Policy are inspired by the Constitution of:
- (a) Canada
- (b) France
- (c) Germany
- (d) Ireland
Answer & solution
Answer: (d) Ireland
The Directive Principles of State Policy in Part IV (Articles 36-51) were taken from the Constitution of Ireland (1937), which itself borrowed the idea from the Spanish Constitution of 1931.
Dr Ambedkar called them the novel feature of the Constitution.
Revision note — Borrowed features of the Indian Constitution
• Ireland: Directive Principles, the method of electing the President (electoral college), and nomination of members to the Rajya Sabha.
• Britain: parliamentary government, rule of law, single citizenship, cabinet system, writs, bicameralism, legislative procedure.
• USA: Fundamental Rights, judicial review, independence of the judiciary, impeachment of the President, removal of judges, the post of Vice-President.
• Canada: federation with a strong Centre, residuary powers with the Centre, appointment of Governors by the Centre, advisory jurisdiction of the Supreme Court.
• Germany (Weimar): suspension of Fundamental Rights during an Emergency. France: the ideals of republic, liberty, equality and fraternity in the Preamble.
• Australia: Concurrent List, freedom of trade and commerce (Article 301), joint sitting of the two Houses.
• USSR: Fundamental Duties and the ideal of justice in the Preamble. South Africa: procedure for amendment and election of Rajya Sabha members. Japan: procedure established by law.
• Directive Principles are non-justiciable (Article 37) but fundamental in the governance of the country; Fundamental Rights (Part III) are justiciable.
Do not mix these up
• Ireland vs USA — Ireland gave the Directive Principles; the USA gave the Fundamental Rights.
• Canada vs Australia — Canada gave the strong-Centre federation and residuary powers; Australia gave the Concurrent List and the joint sitting.
Also asked from this topic: the source of the Directive Principles (Ireland); whether DPSPs are justiciable (no, unlike Fundamental Rights); the Article on the Uniform Civil Code (Article 44).